The first time I saw this title, I had a feeling it was going to be a great book- given my predilection for sad, even depressing stories. What I didn’t realize at that moment was why I was going to like it so much and, that while poignant, it would leave me with a smile on my face.
I discovered this book in a non traditional way. I love audiobooks and I definitely have favorite narrators (and ones that have ruined the books they’ve read). I’ll probably write a future post on some of my favorite narrators later. That being said, some of the best audiobook readers I’ve found are actors. Which only makes sense. One of my top picks as an actor and narrator is David Tennant. I found this book after searching for books he had narrated. No doubt his amazing voice acting skills enhanced the book experience for me, but this story certainly stands on its own merit.
As a side tip, if your looking for new books to love, search not only fave authors but also favorite audiobook narrators, I have found tons of amazing books this way!
Back to My Sister Lives On the Mantelpiece. This is a moving story of a young boy who’s family experiences an unimaginable tragedy, the death of a daughter and sister, and how his family come to terms with the loss. Some in a healthy way, others in a destructive way. Sometimes utterly crushing, other times uplifting, this story portrays all the real, messy consequences of violence and loss. Especially those that happen long after the funeral is over.
One thing that struck me from the first sentence is the choice to have the story told from the perspective of a ten year old boy – the main character, Jamie. He is simultaneously exactly as a ten year old should be and much too grown up for his years. Jaime just wants to be normal, and he is. He loves Spiderman and football (soccer- this book takes place in England, a plus in my opinion), he wants to make friends at school and wants both his parents to come to Teacher Conferences. But his Mum doesn’t live with them anymore, and his Dad- completely consumed in grief- barely realizes he has two children who are still alive. Hearing the difficulties and very grown up problems of Jamie’s family through his innocent, young eyes adds a layer of heartbreak that couldn’t be achieved without telling the story in his voice. Brilliant choice by the author Annabel Pitcher.
Is it a clean read?
Yes, there are a few mild swears here and there. There are references to an affair and to the violent death of Jamie’s sister. Neither of these things are described in detail. Given that this book is told from the perspective of a child even the adult themes are told in a very innocent way. I’d rate it PG.
Likability? 5/5 I’ve re-listened to it a couple of times. It’s a great story. Also, seriously consider checking out the audio version, if available, it’s awesome!
Sarah's Library 